Negligent Discharge

The #1 community for Gun Owners of the Northeast

Member Benefits:

  • No ad networks!
  • Discuss all aspects of firearm ownership
  • Discuss anti-gun legislation
  • Buy, sell, and trade in the classified section
  • Chat with Local gun shops, ranges, trainers & other businesses
  • Discover free outdoor shooting areas
  • View up to date on firearm-related events
  • Share photos & video with other members
  • ...and so much more!
  • Darkemp

    Ultimate Member
    Aug 18, 2009
    7,811
    Marylandistan
    This is why I don’t keep anything chambered while storing. Cameras, alarms, physical door security give me time to chamber a semi. If I didn’t think that was good enough I’d probably keep a revolver in my bedside safe. When I take off my CCW I drop magazine, and rack repeatedly visually verifying the chamber and round that was expelled.
     

    Crosseye Dominant

    Ultimate Member
    Sep 1, 2018
    1,027
    Your cousin was the only one in that room professional enough to handle the .40

     

    Threeband

    The M1 Does My Talking
    Dec 30, 2006
    25,338
    Carroll County
    “I could have sworn the chamber was empty, because I checked.” :shrug:

    I didn’t realize the mag was loaded. Actually put one IN the chamber. :facepalm:

    Fortunately, had muzzle in a safe direction and 94 year old 1” thick oak floors stopped the .380 without penetrating the ceiling.

    “What was that?”

    ”I dropped something” :innocent0

    Minwax wood filler is my friend.

    No alcohol was involved. Just dumbassery.

    That doesn't speak well to .380 penetration.
    Obviously I need to upgrade my pocket carry.

    This is why I don’t keep anything chambered while storing. Cameras, alarms, physical door security give me time to chamber a semi. If I didn’t think that was good enough I’d probably keep a revolver in my bedside safe. When I take off my CCW I drop magazine, and rack repeatedly visually verifying the chamber and round that was expelled.


    Rather than repeatedly chambering and clearing the same round, it might be better to leave your carry gun in it's holster when you take it off.
     

    lazarus

    Ultimate Member
    Jun 23, 2015
    13,741
    I was visiting family in GA the last week. While there my nephew was showing off some stuff he had in the safe. At one point he had his M&P .40 out to show. He cleared the gun and as he did my brain registered a round entering the chamber. Before I had a chance to say anything he pulled the trigger (he seems to do this after clearing). Standing looking into the ejection port I am surprised I was not hit in the face with the brass, but the sound was incredibly loud. People upstairs thought something had fallen in the basement.

    Thankfully no one was hurt. The metal flamingo didn't fare well though.

    We had a good discussion about this afterwards, when I could hear something again.

    Slow down. He was excited about the toys and was going too fast.
    Don't drink and handle guns. He had had a beer and a whiskey and he admitted that he didn't have clarity of thought.
    He believed he had removed the magazine. I have made it a habit of looking at the magazine and confirming the ammo I have loaded. It forces the thought process.
    Don't pull the trigger unless you really need to. I am not sure why he feels the need to pull the trigger before storage, but has become part of the habit.

    He is still mortified by the incident, and I can't say I blame him.
    I am glad everyone is okay. I don't touch guns or open my safe if I've had anything at all to drink (maybe it if was an emergency. Not like you can plan for a break-in. Well, I'll adjust that. I don't open my safe to fingerbang guns. Since I do keep a bit of cash in there (not a lot, but a couple of hundred bucks on hand), and I've had occasion for a "oh, I owe you some money, let me grab that for you". But yeah, drop magazine, check/clear chamber. In that order. Always.

    Hopefully it was a good learning lesson. Often the negative ones stick the best.

    So far in life I've never found a gun loaded when I didn't think it was. I have had a few times a gun went click when I thought it should have gone bang. That's as much sometimes cycling a bolt back far enough to eject a round, but not far enough to pick-up the next (My Howas do this for sure. You cycle slowly and they hang up after ejecting, but really want to go another tenth of an inch to get behind the rim of the next round. Cycle with some intention behind it and no problems. Cycle slowly trying to leave the brass on the bench and you have to be careful you cycled far enough).

    That's in part that I never ever leave guns loaded. Yup, even the bedside gun. If I had a carry gun on me, yes it would be loaded. But eject mag, clear chamber, upon getting home to put it away. If the second to cycle the slide is too long, I was probably already SOL.

    But I always check a gun when I take it out of the safe. Heck, I always check a gun before I pull the trigger on it or do anything else cleaning/smithy on it. Even if I'd cleared it a few minutes ago and put it on my bench. Paranoia for sure. I plan to never have an ND.

    Well, never have an ND that was from carelessness. I've had NDs because of mechanical issues or poor shooting stance. I doubled my Garand once from a rest because I didn't have it in to my shoulder very tight in heavy winter clothing. And my G34 was doubling at the range this past week, but that was a mechanical issue. The trigger bar angle wasn't right, so there wasn't enough overlap on the striker. It was fine when I installed it at home. It was even fine on my last range trip, when it was about 60F. But at about 38F outside in the morning, I guess there was just enough shrinkage the trigger bar was slipping off the striker when I released the trigger. The first one was a shock, but both rounds landed on the target. The second one I was prepared, because I wasn't sure if I'd just yanked the trigger really quick. Nope, fired on the release. Eject mag, clear gun. Take gun home, fixed. Awaiting another range trip to check it, but there is visually sufficient overlap now and it hand cycles properly without doubling after throwing it in my fridge freezer for 15 minutes.
     
    Last edited:

    lazarus

    Ultimate Member
    Jun 23, 2015
    13,741
    My floors are the exception. Certainly NOT the rule in more modern (post WWII) homes. And at an angle, 1” is more like 1.5” of extremely hard, aged wood.

    Not .5” hardwood or engineered hardwood over particleboard.
    Just curious, oak over subfloor? Or oak planks directly on the joists? I don't particularly care about the penetration, I am just curious how the house was constructed. Most newer houses from the 1950s on at least would be plank over 3/4 plywood. So in most cases you'd be talking somewhere around 1 3/8-1 3/4" total thickness depending on how thick the flooring is over the subfloor.
     

    platekiller

    Ultimate Member
    Jun 7, 2011
    1,780
    Martinsburg, WV
    If he were paying attention.

    I always rack more than once even after checking the magwell. Eyeballing an empty magwell is a good idea.
    I always rack 3 times. Hard to ignore rounds popping out if you leave mag in by accident.

    I go over gun safety with my 7 and 10 year old sons. I go over the big 4 (treat loaded, safe direction, trigger finger, know backstop). We also go over what to do if they are at someone’s house and a gun gets involved or they are a gun laying around. My thought is it’s not as fascinating at a friends, etc if I allow them to know and handle guns in a safe environment.
     

    Biggfoot44

    Ultimate Member
    Aug 2, 2009
    33,297
    [QUOTE="eruby, post: 6903890, member: 2381"




    Wouldn't that be a premature discharge?
    [/QUOTE]

    Premature would have to do with the timing . Accidental would have to do with the placement .
     

    Biggfoot44

    Ultimate Member
    Aug 2, 2009
    33,297
    Your cousin was the only one in that room professional enough to handle the .40


    I get the humorous reference , but there's a big difference.

    OP's Nephew still followed the safety rule of having pointed in safe-ish direction .

    Three overlapping safety rules here , following any one of them could , and did prevent injury .

    Ammo in gun
    Pull trigger
    Muzzle in safe direction


    Certain parts of the action shooting world ingrain. " ..... And pull trigger to show safe " . This habit can and does carry over to gun handling in general .

    The other approach common in LE - ish universe ( and methods evolved from that linage) is " ..... Lock back slide/ open cylinder , check gun , and show safe gun to RO " . Teaches shooter to double check own gun , and reduces autopilot ADs .
     

    RFBfromDE

    W&C MD, UT, PA
    MDS Supporter
    Aug 21, 2022
    12,745
    The Land of Pleasant Living
    Just curious, oak over subfloor? Or oak planks directly on the joists? I don't particularly care about the penetration, I am just curious how the house was constructed. Most newer houses from the 1950s on at least would be plank over 3/4 plywood. So in most cases you'd be talking somewhere around 1 3/8-1 3/4" total thickness depending on how thick the flooring is over the subfloor.
    Good point.

    I have not observed the second level subfloor but I have seen the 1st level (From the basement) and there is a .5”X 6” wide T&G laid at a diagonal over 2”X8” wood beams.

    So yeah. There was a shitload of wood for that .380 to go thru.

    BTW it did expand. I could not back it out of the rather clean hole it made. (I was so rattled it took a while to find)

    ”Why are you opening all the windows up there?”

    “Oh, ah, it’s kinda stuffy. Needs fresh air!” :innocent0
     
    Last edited:

    FrankZ

    Liberty = Responsibility
    MDS Supporter
    Oct 25, 2012
    3,366
    I get the humorous reference , but there's a big difference.

    OP's Nephew still followed the safety rule of having pointed in safe-ish direction .

    Three overlapping safety rules here , following any one of them could , and did prevent injury .

    Ammo in gun
    Pull trigger
    Muzzle in safe direction


    Certain parts of the action shooting world ingrain. " ..... And pull trigger to show safe " . This habit can and does carry over to gun handling in general .

    The other approach common in LE - ish universe ( and methods evolved from that linage) is " ..... Lock back slide/ open cylinder , check gun , and show safe gun to RO " . Teaches shooter to double check own gun , and reduces autopilot ADs .
    Very much. The gun was not pointed at anyone AND it was pointed in a downward angle.
     

    Users who are viewing this thread

    Latest posts

    Forum statistics

    Threads
    275,603
    Messages
    7,288,048
    Members
    33,487
    Latest member
    Mikeymike88

    Latest threads

    Top Bottom