- Aug 17, 2011
- 26,172
Here's the cure all, get them both. You can never have to many handguns.
There's the first right answer!
Keep Going Back and Forth Between Glock or M&P...
- Thread starter Kevmo
- Start date
The #1 community for Gun Owners of the Northeast
Member Benefits:
No ad networks! Discuss all aspects of firearm ownership Discuss anti-gun legislation Buy, sell, and trade in the classified section Chat with Local gun shops, ranges, trainers & other businesses Discover free outdoor shooting areas View up to date on firearm-related events Share photos & video with other members ...and so much more!
Member Benefits:
There's the first right answer!
BUFF7MM
☠Buff➐㎣☠
There's the first right answer!
I get one right every once in awhile, about once a year.
- Aug 17, 2011
- 26,172
I get one right every once in awhile, about once a year.
What's the saying about a broken clock...
I got my one right for the year, so it's back to being my normal dumbass self...
balext
Active Member
It's a personal choice. Get out and shoot them both.. I have multiple models of each and like them all.
bitterkenny
Meh
When faced with the same choice a few months ago, I went with the Gen 4 Glocks. Even though the M&P had a better trigger and looked better, the Gen 4 had a better overall feel and balance for me. The proven reputation and bigger after market for the Glocks sealed the deal.
I went Gen 4 over Gen 3 because the grip texture felt more secure. I was also confident Glock worked out their spring and ejector issues.
After getting Gloxworks triggers on my pistols, I know I made the right choice.
I went Gen 4 over Gen 3 because the grip texture felt more secure. I was also confident Glock worked out their spring and ejector issues.
After getting Gloxworks triggers on my pistols, I know I made the right choice.
BlueHeeler
Ultimate Member
Correct or buy both, as said.
Any minor differences between the two you will ignore after a bit of practice and you are comfortable.
Ruzo
Ultimate Member
I have 11 Glocks , that I shoot. A lot, and 2 M&P's collecting dust in my safe..
Contact Glock, they will send you the new "30274" ejector to fix the "brass in the face issue".
AliasNeo07
Ultimate Member
I've been thinking about this a lot lately as well. Both my Glocks have been 100% in over 10k rounds. Can't ask for much more than that. All this talk of Gen 4 failures (mine are gen 3) are probably blown out of proportion...since it's the internet. People don't go to Glocktalk and other sites to say their glocks are working great, usually. It is expected. The threads are always about the failures.
I think it's been well established that some of the 9mm Gen 4 Glocks had extractor/ejector/RSA issues...whatever. They may or not be resolved. I'm considering a G21 SF vs G21 Gen 4...so the gen 4/gen 3 issue isn't as big since it's a .45 model and they've been pretty solid.
That being said, a lot of people REALLY like the feel of the M&P. The ergos are nice. I've only shot about 50 rounds through one...and it did feel good. My only gripe was the trigger. I shoot mostly glocks so I am used to/prefer that distinct, audible and tactile trigger reset. But apparently they fixed that on the M&P shield, and that trigger will soon be making its way to the full M&P line. I'd say hold both, see which feels better, and go with it.
I think it's been well established that some of the 9mm Gen 4 Glocks had extractor/ejector/RSA issues...whatever. They may or not be resolved. I'm considering a G21 SF vs G21 Gen 4...so the gen 4/gen 3 issue isn't as big since it's a .45 model and they've been pretty solid.
That being said, a lot of people REALLY like the feel of the M&P. The ergos are nice. I've only shot about 50 rounds through one...and it did feel good. My only gripe was the trigger. I shoot mostly glocks so I am used to/prefer that distinct, audible and tactile trigger reset. But apparently they fixed that on the M&P shield, and that trigger will soon be making its way to the full M&P line. I'd say hold both, see which feels better, and go with it.
Gen 2 Glock
The grips (ridges between the fingers) on the Gen 3 & 4 just don't feel right to me.
The M&P feels good to me, but I have no reason to switch platforms.
I agree. I'd like to find a clean Gen 2 Glock in 9mm.
Name Taken
Ultimate Member
I have 11 Glocks , that I shoot. A lot, and 2 M&P's collecting dust in my safe..
Mine had the new parts from the factory with a build date of 04/12
Still was getting hot brass to the face 1-2 rounds a magazine using everything from 115 garabage ammo to 147 HP rounds.
Sent it back..they said no issues found...I'll see when I shot it again.
revwood
Cynical Optimist
i can't make up my mind...
i was going to purchase either one in 357sig
and then get a stock 9mm barrel for both for target practice/range....
AHHHHHHHH help me make up my mind!
In my humble opinion you shoulod go with a Gen 3 Glock and not look back. I have a (Gen 1) 17 and a (Gen 3) 26 and dearly love them both. M&Ps are good pistols too, but for my money (and life) give me a Glock any day!
mrozowjj
Ultimate Member
That's not really a valid point though. I mean the Ford Model T was the first and every car since then has copied it in one way or another, but at no point would I recommend a Ford Model T to anyone.
I'm not saying you shouldn't get a Glock, both the Glock and the M&P are damn good guns. But "Glock came first" isn't really a good reason to buy one.
- Aug 17, 2011
- 26,172
Not exactly true, striker fired pistols have been around far longer than Glock has been, I have a 1908 Colt that's striker fired, production date of 1919.
SCARCQB
Get Opp my rawn, Plick!
My Glock 32 in 357 SIG is my standard CCW gun.. That says a lot, considering that I have many to choose from.
The only mod it required was the addition of Tritium sights. This is a pistol that does not know the meaning of " malfunction"
I think Brad shot this gun sometime ago...Besides, If you are like me and cant keep anything stock ( range toys) , you cant go wrong with a Glock. Most add ons are cheap and can be done at home with simple tools.
The only mod it required was the addition of Tritium sights. This is a pistol that does not know the meaning of " malfunction"
I think Brad shot this gun sometime ago...Besides, If you are like me and cant keep anything stock ( range toys) , you cant go wrong with a Glock. Most add ons are cheap and can be done at home with simple tools.
Ooops
Former Navy Bubblehead
I have 2 Glocks and 1 m&p. I like all three. You're probably good with whatever choice you make.
- Aug 17, 2011
- 26,172
Don't think I've scratched .357 Sig off my list yet, I've got time in with your 1911, but that's about it...
I need some NFA fun, today was my b-day and I didn't get to go to the range...
Scott92
Member
I have a G19 gen4 that used to eject brass into my face as well. I took it to a glock armorer at a recent Glock Shooting Sports Foundation event in PA and he installed an upgraded ejector. It was at least twice as thick. Now it send brass so far away from me I have trouble picking out mine from people in lanes at the range next to me! YMMV, but best part was that it was a free swap. You might want to look into that if brass is hitting your head.
Maverick0313
Retired and loving it
Have Glock 19, M&P Pro 9.....gotta tell you I really prefer the M&P.....
DGI
Active Member
I was torn between the two as well... I ended up buying Glocks.
Cheaper to buy, cheaper to upgrade (if needed), 15 min youtube video and i detail strip it, I shoot it just fine for what it is (it aint no 1911
) I can beat it to hell and wont mind if it gets scratched up.
Currently own a G21 Gen3 and a G36. G30 is next on my list and maybe a G17 or G19.
Cheaper to buy, cheaper to upgrade (if needed), 15 min youtube video and i detail strip it, I shoot it just fine for what it is (it aint no 1911
) I can beat it to hell and wont mind if it gets scratched up. Currently own a G21 Gen3 and a G36. G30 is next on my list and maybe a G17 or G19.
