Clinton
THOMAS, Chief Judge
McKEOWN
WARDLAW
W. FLETCHER
Regan
O'SCANNLAIN
Bush
CLIFTON
BYBEE
CALLAHAN
IKUTA
Obama
FRIEDLAND
Trump
R. NELSON
We’re likely screwed here unless a D flips. Clifton was the original dissent in the 3 judge Young panel.
However the logic needed to find that a permit scheme that never issues permits is constitutional is definitely a Herculean task