Woollard ?

[gruntz03]

How big of a part, if any, did the existence of the HPRB play in the 4th Circuits reversal of the District Court Decision in Woollard?

If the MGA does away with the board, does that invite a reopening of the case?

 

[krucam]

How big of a part, if any, did the existence of the HPRB play in the 4th Circuits reversal of the District Court Decision in Woollard?

If the MGA does away with the board, does that invite a reopening of the case?

Only a concealed carry win at the Supreme Court would precipitate a new case at CA4. The final chances for that are only coming from the 9th Circuit, Nichols & Baker are still alive I believe

 

[danb]

Who would have thought DC and Illinois would be shall issue before Maryland.

The MD skates on thin ice and tempts fate because Frosh has them all smoking medical marijuana.

MD legislature should push gun control really hard, ignoring fiscal issues and taxes. That worked out well for Anthony Brown.

 

[GTOGUNNER]

I think a Williams type case, if a permit was applied for and denied, might tip the scale in Maryland. A 21yo black male in Baltimore should be given a permit as he is in a target group to be killed. He has good and substantial as far as I am concerned. We need to find this person.

Sent from the 3rd Rock

 

[j_h_smith]

I think it would have to open up another look at it. Who knows?

 

[Gryphon]

It wouldn’t reopen the Woollard case. However, if they disband the Board and fail to provide a mechanism for due process that would create a new case altogether. They are suggesting the proposed bill will route new appeals to the ALJ’s at the OAH but I have yet to see the text.

 

[rambling_one]

Who would have thought DC and Illinois would be shall issue before Maryland.

I sure didn't see it coming.

 

[mxrider]

We actually don't need to have any changes to bring forth another Woolard type case (challenging the constitutionality of G&S). Now that there is a circuit split, challenging the G&S clause would likely end up at the SC.

 

[press1280]

It wouldn’t reopen the Woollard case. However, if they disband the Board and fail to provide a mechanism for due process that would create a new case altogether. They are suggesting the proposed bill will route new appeals to the ALJ’s at the OAH but I have yet to see the text.

I doubt the overturning of Woollard had anything to do with the HRPB being in existence. There's always ways to appeal a permit denial, whether it's NJ, NY,CA,exc.
The court didn't like public carry, period.

 

[GTOGUNNER]

gotta say, LGOC.

 

[krucam]

gotta say, LGOC.

If OC somehow ekes out of CA9 with Nichols, Baker, Young...that would open up a channel in CA4....

 

[GTOGUNNER]

If OC somehow ekes out of CA9 with Nichols, Baker, Young...that would open up a channel in CA4....

That would be great.

Sent from the 3rd Rock

 

[Schipperke]

It wouldn’t reopen the Woollard case. However, if they disband the Board and fail to provide a mechanism for due process that would create a new case altogether. They are suggesting the proposed bill will route new appeals to the ALJ’s at the OAH but I have yet to see the text.

http://mgaleg.maryland.gov/2018RS/bills/hb/hb0819f.pdf