NY ordered to answer to SCOTUS

[Boxcab]

This is the government not the private sector. Not sure the government runs like that. What I've seen over the years with the 2A cases is that the legislatures and courts don't care what the SCOTUS has decided. They are going to continue to make laws and lower courts agree with the new laws that are the same as what the SCOTUS just said they can't do.

I see the SCOTUS taking this appeal, fast tracking it, and sending back to the lower court with the language they used, as a shot across the bow. In the past 100 years this has not been done with any 2A case I am aware of.

Read the ruling above again (using your "mom" or "dad" voice). It is a warning that the games that worked in the past, are no longer acceptable.



.

Sent from my SM-G781U using Tapatalk

 

[Abuck]

I think Thomas is playing the long game and we may stand to get some more precedent out of this so instead of just NY it helps all of us in socialist replublics like MD and CA and others

Many lower courts have repeatedly shown to not be entrusted with this right. Although I think (hope) the one step forward, two steps back on the 2A dance has now flipped. The recent TRO in NJ was a refreshing change.

I sincerely hope that this is it. If Justice Thomas needs to step to the plate again, he’s going to swing the big bat.
Could you imagine the bed wetting, teeth grinding, and wailing of “F¥CK around and find out, Constitutional Carry Motherf¥ckers!”

Lol, I don’t expect it to go that far, but one can dream.

 

[KingClown]

Many lower courts have repeatedly shown to not be entrusted with this right. Although I think (hope) the one step forward, two steps back on the 2A dance has now flipped. The recent TRO in NJ was a refreshing change.

I sincerely hope that this is it. If Justice Thomas needs to step to the plate again, he’s going to swing the big bat.
Could you imagine the bed wetting, teeth grinding, and wailing of “F¥CK around and find out, Constitutional Carry Motherf¥ckers!”

Lol, I don’t expect it to go that far, but one can dream.

I really hope he smacks them hard. Its in the COTUS which makes it Fed jurisdition. Id like to see him take in wholly from the states.

 

[rambling_one]

In this case, I would enjoy seeing that. If they have to step in again, I think a good bit of that courteousness goes away, with a much more direct result. A few of these courts could probably use some tyranny directed at them. Such as the 9th. How can they be so wrong, so often?

I’d rather not have arrests being made enforcing unconstitutional laws. I know the thought is that having patience is for the greater good. So I will hope for a very short leash with this, and that expedited, means just that.

I remember Judge Legg’s ruling in Wollard, several years ago. I thought I would have a MD carry permit back then. These things take too long IMHO.

Amen!

 

[Mister F]

I think Thomas is playing the long game and we may stand to get some more precedent out of this so instead of just NY it helps all of us in socialist replublics like MD and CA and others

Thomas is very serious and sees the racist background of “gun control” law history, and he is not inclined to let it stand. But he is also a professional, extremely senior jurist and knows doing things the right way is important.

We would prefer things be done right…not “right now”.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[owldo]

Second Circuit will sit on it until SCOTUS changes to liberal, then rule against plantiffs.

They can try ... but they were also told to expedite the process !

 

[Abuck]

We would prefer things be done right…not “right now”.

At the last days of my 57th year, the petulant child in me says “Booooo!”

Do what’s right, especially for exercising an enumerated right, when you have that opportunity. I can understand that I am not as smart, educated, or informed as Justice Thomas, and that I have no choice, but to trust the process. Hopefully I’ll still be alive to witness and practice the results.

As a PA resident, I think it’s extremely unfair that I have spent several decades practicing a right mostly denied to those of you in MD, and other states. And I dislike being stripped of that right by crossing the border in to MD.

 

[whistlersmother]

eruby DGAF as WWNC

Sigh.

I lost trolling points with that attempt.

I have regressed to Troll Level Novice...

 

[SW51]

Concealed means Concealed

 

[swinokur]

Um it’s a Wear and Carry Permit.

Stop with the concealed crap

 

[Bertfish]

Um it’s a Wear and Carry Permit.

Stop with the concealed crap

Go back and read again

He means what they can't see they can't hassle you for

 

[Garet Jax]

Um it’s a Wear and Carry Permit.

Stop with the concealed crap

It won't be when MGA is finished with it.

 

[swinokur]

Go back and read again

He means what they can't see they can't hassle you for

Read 4-206. He can hassle you if he sees printing

 

[swinokur]

I OC in front of two MSP troopers at Mission BBQ in Westminster last night.

Had a nice convo with them.

BGOS on display yet again

 

[eruby]

I OC in front of two MSP troopers at Mission BBQ in Westminster last night.

Had a nice convo with them.

BGOS on display yet again

Pretty sure most of the concealed comments are if Maryland passes SB1, emulating New York.

You know I know you ARE the man, my friend!

 

[SW51]

Not prohibited, not recommended as may result in revocation of your permit. Good luck

 

[teratos]

Not prohibited, not recommended as may result in revocation of your permit. Good luck

Live in the dark and bow before your masters.

Some of us are free men, and live that way.

 

[eruby]

Not prohibited, not recommended as may result in revocation of your permit. Good luck

What?

On this you are wrong.

 

[Bertfish]

Perp walk

********

 

[Bertfish]

Not prohibited, not recommended as may result in revocation of your permit. Good luck

Based on what?