Cargill v Garland (5th Circuit Bump Stock Case)

[Inigoes]

Would they issue a decision, or remand for redecision at CA level in light of changes to Chevron? And didn't GOV try to waive right to deference in anticipation of Chevron undergoing substantial change?

We have seen this in the past 2A cases like in Bruen. Once the main opinion is issued, all of the similar cases that the SCOTUS granted, released a succint opinion stating see the main opinion like what happened in Bianchi. Even though the SCOTUS ruled in our favor, the 4th CA is definitely dragging their feet.

As for the second question: I do not know.

 

[Kharn]

I could see the court enjoying the 1-2 punch of the fishing cases and Cargill, saying excessive regulations beyond the intent of Congress are bad, and an agency sidestepping Congress's plain text is inconceivable.

Cargill has received an extension until 22 Jan for their response brief. So much for some snow day reading.

 

[Kharn]

Respondent's (Cargill's) brief is up

I really like it so far.

 

[pcfixer]

Garland v. Cargill​

Docket No.​	Op. Below​	Argument​	​	​	​	​
22-976	5th Cir.	Feb 28, 2024

 

[pcfixer]

Respondent's (Cargill's) brief is up

I really like it so far.

I 100% agree.

V. THE COURT SHOULD DIRECT THE DISTRICT COURT TO “HOLD UNLAWFUL” AND “SET ASIDE” ATF’S FINAL RULE

 

[Fushigi Ojisan]

And the left's perspective

The Supreme Court will decide whether to let civilians own automatic weapons

Garland v. Cargill asks whether gun makers can evade the ban on machine guns with a device called a bump stock.

www.vox.com

Sent from my SM-T733 using Tapatalk

 

[P-12 Norm]

And the left's perspective

The Supreme Court will decide whether to let civilians own automatic weapons

Garland v. Cargill asks whether gun makers can evade the ban on machine guns with a device called a bump stock.

www.vox.com

Sent from my SM-T733 using Tapatalk

I find it amusing that the Leftists of the 60's that didn't trust the government at all, are now so enamored of it that they are asking it to regulate all aspects of life. Truly proof that Liberalism/Leftist ideology is a mental illness.

 

[HaveBlue]

I find it amusing that the Leftists of the 60's that didn't trust the government at all, are now so enamored of it that they are asking it to regulate all aspects of life. Truly proof that Liberalism/Leftist ideology is a mental illness.

This inconsistency confused me for longer than it should have. Despite what they say, they don’t like anyone or anything that doesn’t agree with them completely.

 

[JohnnyE]

This inconsistency confused me for longer than it should have. Despite what they say, they don’t like anyone or anything that doesn’t agree with them completely.

They like it when it is their servant, but should it turn and become their master, what is plan B? Oh, the founders thought of that.

 

[krucam]

Oral Arguments this Wednesday, Feb 28th

 

[rbird7282]

And the left's perspective

The Supreme Court will decide whether to let civilians own automatic weapons

Garland v. Cargill asks whether gun makers can evade the ban on machine guns with a device called a bump stock.

www.vox.com

Sent from my SM-T733 using Tapatalk

Pretty soon they'll outlaw belt loops

 

[krucam]

Link for 10am Arguments. Not sure if this is the Live or Post feed...

Arguments Audios

 

[Apd09]

Link for 10am Arguments. Not sure if this is the Live or Post feed...

Arguments Audios

Link for 10am Arguments. Not sure if this is the Live or Post feed...

Arguments Audios

Post, the 1st paragraph on the page literally says “The audio recordings of all oral arguments heard by the Supreme Court of the United States are posted on this website on the same day an argument is heard by the Court.”


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[krucam]

Plaintiff Cargill is in town...

 

[Blacksmith101]

I believe this is the link for the live argument:

Live Oral Argument Audio

Also being covered on Langley Outdoors Academy:

 

[Inigoes]

Post, the 1st paragraph on the page literally says “The audio recordings of all oral arguments heard by the Supreme Court of the United States are posted on this website on the same day an argument is heard by the Court.”


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Live streaming now

 

[delaware_export]

pro2a guy let them take him down a rabbit hole. buttons buttons buttons.

 

[FrankZ]

pro2a guy let them take him down a rabbit hole. buttons buttons buttons.

He was soundly abused.

 

[JohnnyE]

From a technology standpoint, and theory of operation, a bump stock is an incredibly simple device and easy to understand. I don't get the difficulty some have grasping it.

 

[krucam]

Love these guys...