Benelli M4 Magazine tube question

[Baldheaded]

I just got a Benelli M4 and am interested in getting either the full length magazine tube or the magazine extension. Cost wise there isn't that much of a difference for some reason. From what I have read replacing the extension is pretty simple. But with the full length tube you need to heat the tube to change it due to the lock tight on the threads. But what I really would like to know is what is the advantages and disadvantages of going with one over the other. I would like some advise please. Also if I go with the full length tube would it be worth it to get it in titanium over steel? The titanium weighs a little less but is $100 more. I have been looking at a company called Freedom Fighter Tactical for their M4 parts.

 

[Sage954]

Watch the Freedom Fighter Tactical video on 922r compliance.

 

[Baldheaded]

Watch the Freedom Fighter Tactical video on 922r compliance.

Yeah I know all about changing parts and have to stay in compliance. Sounds crazy to me but it is what it is I guess.

 

[Baldheaded]

Big bucks just to add a couple of shells.......

 

[Baldheaded]

While I am at it I might as well ask about adding an optic to my M4. I was leaning towards a Holosun 510c gr. Thoughts?

 

[smdub]

IIRC, disassembly can be a little easier w/ a replacement tube as the handguards and stuff don't hit the fat part of the extension and just slide right off. Looks a lot cleaner too.

I made a Ti tube for my Turknelli M4 clone (pics in that thread.) FWIW, Its lighter by exactly what two more 00 Buck shells weigh.

I think a 510C would be a great choice on a shotgun due to the circle/dot.

 

[Ski169]

I went with the full length tube since I thought it just looked cleaner. Not too difficult to swap out.
I elected to go with an RMR on a Scalarworks mount. Lowest mount I could find and works well with the sights.

 

[Baldheaded]

I went with the full length tube since I thought it just looked cleaner. Not too difficult to swap out.
I elected to go with an RMR on a Scalarworks mount. Lowest mount I could find and works well with the sights.

Looks nice. I see you upgraded the bolt release and charging handle also. Did you do any trigger work? What brand parts did you use?

 

[Garet Jax]

I just got a Benelli M4 and am interested in getting either the full length magazine tube or the magazine extension. Cost wise there isn't that much of a difference for some reason. From what I have read replacing the extension is pretty simple. But with the full length tube you need to heat the tube to change it due to the lock tight on the threads. But what I really would like to know is what is the advantages and disadvantages of going with one over the other. I would like some advise please. Also if I go with the full length tube would it be worth it to get it in titanium over steel? The titanium weighs a little less but is $100 more. I have been looking at a company called Freedom Fighter Tactical for their M4 parts.

When I did it, I found this thread on the subject and reached out to the guy (Joseph) mentioned in it. I love the results.

https://forums.benelliusa.com/topic/23803-m4-magazine-tube-titanium-option/

I do not know if it is more or less expensive, but Joseph did right by me.

I bought the rest of the compliance parts from Freedom Fighters Tactical.

 

[El_flasko]

Bought all my parts from freedom fighters tactical as well Aside from the release and bolt knob from GGG.

 

[Baldheaded]

I think the parts from FFT are high quality but at a high cost.

 

[El_flasko]

I think the parts from FFT are high quality but at a high cost.

I agree 100%. I am nothing but pleased with everything I got from them, but nothing was cheap for sure. I still can't get over (not FFT), but the Benelli adjustable stock being damn near $600. That's just absurd. Gotta pay to play I suppose.

 

[Ski169]

Sorry, no trigger work. I might reconsider that later although it wasn’t necessary for me right now. And yeah, that’s the GG&G handle and bolt release. The only thing I don’t like about the handle is that it spins/twists. It’s not locked in like the factory small handle.

 

[Baldheaded]

Sorry, no trigger work. I might reconsider that later although it wasn’t necessary for me right now. And yeah, that’s the GG&G handle and bolt release. The only thing I don’t like about the handle is that it spins/twists. It’s not locked in like the factory small handle.

I don't think I would like a bolt release that spins either. I haven't decided if I am going to replace the factory one yet or not. Wish I could just replace the magazine tube and be done but you can't do that and stay compliant so I guess I will be doing some other things too.

 

[Defense Initiative]

Why not just buy a shell carrier and put your savings into your primary firearm?

 

[smdub]

Why not just buy a shell carrier and put your savings into your primary firearm?

The right answer is both. (shell carrier + tube)

 

[Defense Initiative]

The right answer is both. (shell carrier + tube)

Depends on how it’s being used and for what purpose.

 

[Muleskinner]

I installed the 2 shot extension made by Carlson. Cost $60 and was a simple install. The round count is for 2 3/4 in

 

[Baldheaded]

I agree 100%. I am nothing but pleased with everything I got from them, but nothing was cheap for sure. I still can't get over (not FFT), but the Benelli adjustable stock being damn near $600. That's just absurd. Gotta pay to play I suppose.

I would not pay $600 for an adjustable stock.

 

[El_flasko]

I would not pay $600 for an adjustable stock.

I agree. Found one for $500-$550 and still couldn’t justify it. After The full length tube, new follower, spring, and forearm it’s compliant (which is dumb as hell) and I’m happy with the entire gun. I love the GG&G stuff too, but $500-$600 for that stock I just can’t justify personally.

Sorry I ran at the mouth OP, didn’t mean to mini hijack.

BTW - just saw the “no spin” bolt handles on FFT OP. They were $76 I believe.