Smoke Wagon and Blackhawk are radically different. The former is classic cowboy style, with fixed sights, a decent factory action job, and no transfer bar safety. The latter is a modern target revolver, with adjustable sights, a large beefy frame, and (on New Models) a transfer bar safety. Be sure to check out Ruger Vaquero if you lean towards cowboy-style revolvers (with the benefit of a safety bar). I love Blackhawks.