Senate Judiciary GOP Aims to Codify Recent 2nd Amendment Rulings

The #1 community for Gun Owners of the Northeast

Member Benefits:

  • No ad networks!
  • Discuss all aspects of firearm ownership
  • Discuss anti-gun legislation
  • Buy, sell, and trade in the classified section
  • Chat with Local gun shops, ranges, trainers & other businesses
  • Discover free outdoor shooting areas
  • View up to date on firearm-related events
  • Share photos & video with other members
  • ...and so much more!
  • Harrys

    Short Round
    Jul 12, 2014
    3,432
    SOMD
    Eric Mack
    16 March 2023


    All 10 Republican members of the Senate Judiciary Committee have co-sponsored the Respect for the Second Amendment Act to codify recent Supreme Court rulings upholding the constitutional U.S. right to keep and bear arms.

    "I am very pleased that all Senate Judiciary Republicans are speaking with one voice when it comes to supporting the Second Amendment rights recognized by the Supreme Court in the Heller and Bruen decisions," Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., the ranking member, wrote in a statement, while also delivering the announcement in a Thursday news conference. "Now more than ever, it is important that Congress recognize and support that the Second Amendment is an individual right and that the right to bear arms to defend oneself is an integral part of American society."

    With the Democrat attacks on the Second Amendment, Senate Judiciary Republicans want to codify the recent rulings that uphold constitutional law.

    "With this bill, we are ensuring that the rights affirmed by the Supreme Court are part of the federal code — and preventing a future Supreme Court from reversing this decision," Graham continued. "The Respect for the Second Amendment Act will memorialize the holdings in these landmark Supreme Court cases and provide further protection to the Second Amendment."

    The Supreme Court found a New York state law restricting concealed carry was unconstitutional (New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen).

    "It's important that we continue to protect the Second Amendment rights of all law-abiding Americans through legislation like this," Sen. Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, the former Senate Judiciary chairman, said in a statement. "Our history and Constitution are clear. Americans have the right to bear arms. This bill will codify and strengthen many of the court decisions from recent years affirming that right.

    Also co-sponsoring the bill were: Sens. John Cornyn, R-Texas; Mike Lee, R-Utah; Ted Cruz, R-Texas; Josh Hawley, R-Mo.; Tom Cotton, R-Ark.; John Kennedy, R-La.; Thom Tillis, R-N.C.; and Marsha Blackburn, R-Tenn.

    "Law-abiding Americans should not be subjected to arbitrary requirements and government bureaucracy when applying for a concealed carry permit," Cornyn wrote in a statement. "This bill ensures the Second Amendment is protected and Texans can exercise their constitutional right to bear arms, and I'm proud to support it."

    Ultimately, a constitutional amendment applies to all states and cannot be unwound by Democrat-ruled ones like New York, according to Cotton.

    "Last year the Supreme Court verified what the Constitution makes clear, that Americans have undeniable Second Amendment rights that can't be taken away, by the State of New York or anyone else," Cotton wrote in a statement. "Our bill will strengthen the Second Amendment against future attacks and allow law-abiding citizens to challenge attempts to strip them of their rights."

    While the federal judiciary can interpret laws and their application, it remains the Constitution and Congress that writes and passes law, Kennedy added.

    "Congress has the ability to use its authority to guard against state overreach — and that is what this bill does," Kennedy wrote in his statement. "At a time when the constitutional right to keep and bear arms is under attack in courtrooms throughout America, we must ensure that the Supreme Court's decision about the Second Amendment is not only legal precedent but that the law preserves it forever."

    Among the details in the bill:

    • Creates a backstop to any future change from the Supreme Court.
    • Allows to lawsuits "against any law, rule, ordinance, etc., that infringes on Second Amendment rights."
    • Shifts the burden of attorney fees and costs to the government if the private lawsuit wins.
    • Enables courts to strike down state and local gun control laws when they conflict with federal law.




    https://www.newsmax.com/newsfront/senate-judiciary-republicans/2023/03/16/id/1112455/
     

    Afrikeber

    Ultimate Member
    Jan 14, 2013
    6,747
    Urbana, Md.
    Geez this all sounds fantastic but does it apply to all the states or just those signing it?

    Backstopping the SCOTUS Bruen decision so it cannot be changed is great too but does this mean it can still be challenged by the anti states.

    Best part I like is they pay attorneys fees when they file these bogus legal challenges.
     

    Ponder_MD

    Ultimate Member
    Mar 9, 2020
    4,641
    Maryland
    We're now at the part where we're passing laws and resolutions that just say "The Constitution means what it says."
    How ridiculous is that? It's well meaning, but useless.
     

    KingClown

    SOmething Witty
    Jul 29, 2020
    1,186
    Deep Blue MD
    This law is a joke. It specifies history and tradition and leaves out text. Under history and tradition NY would have been fine and we would have lost Bruen. Any time Lindsey Graham is signing onto something you better ask whats the catch.
    This law would set up an angle for more gun control not less. Gun Control was unchecked so long they can claim history and tradition. If they arent going to add text to the history and tradition part this will only stand to damage the Bruen decision. Will we still win probably but lower courts will claim they are following this and we will have to go all the way to SCOTUS for everything.

    Lindsey needs to go along with anyone else signing this law.
     

    kshaw

    Active Member
    Nov 21, 2012
    311
    Gaithersburg, MD
    This law is a joke. It specifies history and tradition and leaves out text. Under history and tradition NY would have been fine and we would have lost Bruen. Any time Lindsey Graham is signing onto something you better ask whats the catch.
    This law would set up an angle for more gun control not less. Gun Control was unchecked so long they can claim history and tradition. If they arent going to add text to the history and tradition part this will only stand to damage the Bruen decision. Will we still win probably but lower courts will claim they are following this and we will have to go all the way to SCOTUS for everything.

    Lindsey needs to go along with anyone else signing this law.
    I suspect that Lindsay Graham is trying to use this to divert attention from his recent support of the Democrat's gun control initiative. I was beginning to develop some respect for him and then he did that.
     

    KingClown

    SOmething Witty
    Jul 29, 2020
    1,186
    Deep Blue MD
    I suspect that Lindsay Graham is trying to use this to divert attention from his recent support of the Democrat's gun control initiative. I was beginning to develop some respect for him and then he did that.
    Dont show him respect. He is a Trojan horse. He had to make abortion front and center before midterms screaming about making it illegal federally with no exceptions. There are many clips if him dogging Trump and praising Biden. Theres the gun control he signed onto and make no mistake this is gun control. They are trying to circumvent the 2A because that would allow NY to claim over 100 years of history and tradition of gun control.
    That one word "Text" History and tradition makes all the difference in the world. Without it gun control will reign supreme. Him and Crenshaw need to go. Mitch does too.
     

    Users who are viewing this thread

    Latest posts

    Forum statistics

    Threads
    275,640
    Messages
    7,289,442
    Members
    33,491
    Latest member
    Wolfloc22

    Latest threads

    Top Bottom