I think this is it. The ejector rod and star look good. The cylinder release does not move.
Remember that I did not disassemble anything.
Building on this, I just played with one of mine and, while the cylinder release is "dead" (meaning pushed in, not springy) with the cylinder open, if I push forward on the release (as in the flat, not serrated part more outboard), it pivots the whole thing out as though the cylinder was in and working right. There is very little spring tension to overcome. So...if your cylinder release does not move at all (even "backwards"), that would seem to narrow down your problem.I just opened the cylinder on my GP100. The cylinder latch will not move with the cylinder open. Also the release pin in the recoil shield is flush with the face of the shield. Hope this helps.
The other thing I did that made it not close was to push the crane forward. It actually moved more than I expected, but even a couple thou (like the thickness of some crud or a brush bristle or string from a patch) forward made it every hard to close and it wouldn't latch.
Keep fiddling and keep us posted.