Do a Google Search on "BSA Arrow of Light plaques" Arrow of Light is the highest award a Cub Scout can earn. The boys track their accomplishments by painting different color bands on a arrow. There are lots of plans out there for display boards. Some would be generic enough for your purpose.Leave them as is and mount them on a board.
Haven't done that in archery but did it while drunkenly playing darts a few years back. Bastards I was playing didn't give me credit for double bullseye on that shot. Still whupped them in the end though and won my $50.