Next 9mm Pistol

pp55ftw · Dec 17, 2019

Hey shooters,

Have a really old/drawn out question for the community but just want to hear opinions from this forum.

Basically in the market for another 9mm semi-auto pistol. Main purpose is HD and range fun, 9mm because of ammo commonality with my other weapons (I stock 5.56 and 9mm only). I already have a Glock 19 which is a duty/main pistol so no need to suggest Glock.

Looking at the following options:

CZ P-10c
SW M&P2.0c
FN 509
or any other suggestions.

Main concerns are reliability, shootability, and just plain fun. Maybe I'm just looking for an excuse to get another gun tbh...so, let's open the flood gates for some healthy debate!

Thanks!

RuralRifleGuy · Dec 17, 2019

I can't comment on the M&P 2.0 Compact directly, but my full-size 2.0 runs flawlessly with every brand of ammo I throw at it and it has a good grip texture. Take a look at the Sig P320's, they have a variety of 9mm options and like Glock magazines are interchangeable. I have an X-Carry which is a nice compromise in size similar to a Glock 19X, the full-sizes are nice, though I don't own 9mm versions of them.

Biggfoot44 · Dec 17, 2019

I'd go so far as to say , if you already have a G19 , no need to suggest another striker fired polymer pistol . If you have emphasis on fun , while still HD capable , go for somthing different , ie a DA/ SA or SA , in a metal frame .

Amongst current production guns , CZ-75/85 family , EAA Witness line duplicates the actual CZ offerings , plus even more additional varients , at reasonable prices . A P series SIG if you are wiling for the $$ . The Beretta Cougar never cought on in the US market , but it is a very interesting and innovative design , and Stoeger's Couger is the exact same pistol made under license in Turkey , at reasonable prices . I am too old school to be accepting of 9mm 1911 , but they are certainly popular now , and widely available from multiple mfg at every point between Budget and if you have to ask .... But if * I * wanted a cocked & locked traditional 9mm , the FM Hi Power is licensed 100% interchangeable w/ Browning , at reasonable prices .

Of course, my wildcard pick is dual cylinder Ruger Blackhawk in .357/ 9mm .

jimbobborg · Dec 17, 2019

Go to a range that rents guns and try out a bunch of them.

Neutron · Dec 17, 2019

If you like 1911's a 9mm might be a good choice. I have an RIA in 9mm and it's been a great shooter. Cheaper to shoot than my 45 and less felt recoil. Would love to have the Springfield 1911 in 9 but almost double the price of the Rock.

Cal68 · Dec 17, 2019

jimbobborg said:
Go to a range that rents guns and try out a bunch of them.

I agree with the above. I've often heard certain guns being highly touted on this and other forums but when I have rented them at a range, I've found that they were simply not for me. I'm sure they are great guns for some people, but they did not work for me.

I know that both of the ranges in Frederick have a variety of guns to rent. You can call ahead of time and see if they have the ones you are looking at.

Cal68

alucard0822 · Dec 17, 2019

No need to try something all that different unless you really want something a G19 can't do or doesn't do as well. Unless you go for something completely different in alloy/steel like a CZ75 or Sig PXXX would probably just get another Glock, maybe a G34, add a RDS on a MOS model for a lot of fun, or a G43 for something fun and small.

Uncle Duke · Dec 17, 2019

Rent a CZ P-01.

FOR ME, the ergonomics of that pistol are amazing. Likewise amazing is the testing that pistol has been subjected to.

Czechnologist · Dec 17, 2019

Another vote for either a CZ-75B or SP-01 since you had 'range fun' as one of your criteria. Your best bet, though, is to go rent several and take note of which ones you like the most. I think it's hard to beat a CZ for the performance you get for the price.

-Z/28- · Dec 17, 2019

Can't go wrong with a Sig P226.

Tungsten · Dec 17, 2019

SP01 or P320

Mightydog · Dec 17, 2019

My next one is a Magnum Research Desert Eagle 1911U. You can also try a Colt Combat Commander. Can’t go wrong with a Colt. Both available from one of our IPs - JLowe’s. Good pricing.

onedash · Dec 17, 2019

I think a SW M&P M2.0 compact is in my future too.

BlueHeeler · Dec 17, 2019

jimbobborg said:
Go to a range that rents guns and try out a bunch of them.

+1

There is no better advice that trying them out for yourself.

Huckleberry · Dec 17, 2019

Here's a voice for old school kool.

Consider a Browning HP.

All modern pistols mentioned like the CZ75 draw their lineage from the BHP.

The BHP was John Moses Browning was 2nd greatest pistol design after the 1911. It could have been his first if he only lived longer so he could have designed it for the 45 ACP

SkiPatrolDude · Dec 17, 2019

my HK VP9 is by far my most accurate pistol. Not speaking to mechanical accuracy as I know all of mine are better than me, but speaking to my ability to put rounds on target. I can pretty easily hit a 3 inch clay pigeon laid upright on my buddies farm at 80 yards.

It has a very "two-stagey" feeling trigger which allows me to take very calculated shots. HK also sights them in at the factory, and mine has been dead on. Despite not having true night sights, the sight picture is among the best that I have. Also, ergonomically it just feels great in the hand.

EODJoe · Dec 17, 2019

I have a late '60s Belgian manufactured FN/Browning Hi-Power and it is one of my absolute favorite pistols. I also have a couple of Sig 9mm that I think are fantastic. One is the M11A1 which is the closest I could find to the P228 since they aren't making new 228s anymore. I trained for protective service work in the Army with a 228 (M11) and it is a great shooter. I also bought a P320 after getting to try out the XM17 and XM18 a few years ago. All are great guns.

Atlbrvs · Dec 17, 2019

How hasn't anybody mentioned the Hi-Point Yeet Cannon?

Kman · Dec 17, 2019

If I bought another 9mm, it would be a Walther PPQ or Browning HP.

fred55 · Dec 17, 2019

Or a Sig 229

Next 9mm Pistol

The #1 community for Gun Owners of the Northeast

Member Benefits:

Member

Active Member

Ultimate Member

Oddball caliber fan

Ultimate Member

Ultimate Member

For great Justice

Ultimate Member

Concerned Citizen

I wanna go fast

Ultimate Member

Ultimate Member

Attachments

Ultimate Member

Ultimate Member

No One of Consequence

Ultimate Member

Sic Semper Tyrannis

Member

Blah, blah, blah

Senior

Users who are viewing this thread

Log in

Forum statistics