CCW Revolver advice?

• Apr 19, 2019

• #1

Luigi2020

Member

Oct 21, 2013

67

Nottingham, MD

I got my MD carry permit a few months ago and I'm thinking of getting a revolver. A friend has a Ruger LCR (9mm) that he carries and is going to let me take it to the range. I've looked at a few different revolvers at shops but I'm open to any suggestions.

Any advice would be greatly appreciated.

 

• Apr 19, 2019

• #2

danb

dont be a dumbass

Feb 24, 2013

22,704

google is your friend, I am not.

Anything before 1998 named Smith and Wesson, Colt, or also Ruger. I have some nearly new in box vintage 1980 and 1970 revolvers that are dead nuts accurate with sweet triggers. 2.5" - 4" barrel is also a good choice although it depends on your body size. I can stow a 4" model 13 and you would never know. You can also find some 7 shot sub 4" barrel 586s as well but they are more rare. Some people can hide a 4", others not. I prefer 357 because it gives me more options. 38 spl is about the same as 9mm and with modern bullet technology you can get good terminal performance. I also prefer the option of single action over the hammerless. My 0.02 is you cant go wrong with anything that fits these parameters and it comes down to grips and what you can comfortably shoot and conceal.

 

• Apr 19, 2019

• #3

RegularJay

NRA & SAF Life Member

MDS Supporter

Sep 20, 2007

1,382

Harford County

Definitely shoot before you buy, I have an S&W airweight snubby, quite concealable but very uncomfortable for me to shoot.

 

• Apr 19, 2019

• #4

O

ohen cepel

Ultimate Member

Feb 2, 2011

4,512

Where they send me.

Several S&W J frames made now without the lock which are worth a look. Ruger also as mentioned. Older Colts are nice if you find one you like.

I'm a big .38 fan in small guns. 9mm isn't a bad option if you have one already and prefer to keep the ammo situation simple but that limits you in options.

.327 is an option which I really like but I wouldn't suggest it to most people.

Nice thing about a revolver is you should be able to find a grip that you like as there are more possibilities there by design, unlike an auto which can only be X dimensions to hold the mag.

 

• Apr 19, 2019

• #5

danb

dont be a dumbass

Feb 24, 2013

22,704

google is your friend, I am not.

ohen cepel said:

Nice thing about a revolver is you should be able to find a grip that you like as there are more possibilities there by design, unlike an auto which can only be X dimensions to hold the mag.

Click to expand...

The main nice thing about a revolver is that you pull the trigger and it goes bang!

 

• Apr 19, 2019

• #6

3

303_enfield

Ultimate Member

May 30, 2007

4,673

DelMarVa

Old school pre-lock S&W. I carried Mod 37 for years.

 

• Apr 19, 2019

• #7

Sundazes

Throbbing Member

MDS Supporter

Nov 13, 2006

21,537

Arkham

I would get a BFR in 45/70.

 

• Apr 19, 2019

• #8

Luigi2020

Member

Oct 21, 2013

67

Nottingham, MD

danb said:

The main nice thing about a revolver is that you pull the trigger and it goes bang!

Click to expand...

That's why I'm looking to get a revolver for my EDC. I currently carry a Sig P938. Really like it, but carrying it "cocked and locked" still feels odd to me. Not sure why.

 

• Apr 19, 2019

• #9

Kman

Blah, blah, blah

Dec 23, 2010

11,991

Eastern shore

If I was going to carry a revolver it would be that LCR in 9mm.
Dependable, light and prefer 9mm ballistic options.

 

• Apr 19, 2019

• #10

danb

dont be a dumbass

Feb 24, 2013

22,704

google is your friend, I am not.

Luigi2020 said:

That's why I'm looking to get a revolver for my EDC. I currently carry a Sig P938. Really like it, but carrying it "cocked and locked" still feels odd to me. Not sure why.

Click to expand...

Trust me, the worst thing you can do for your wallet is start looking at "used" revolvers on gunbroker or in a consignment store.

 

• Apr 19, 2019

• #11

danb

dont be a dumbass

Feb 24, 2013

22,704

google is your friend, I am not.

sundazes said:

I would get a BFR in 45/70.

Click to expand...

Lol.

 

• Apr 19, 2019

• #12

Luigi2020

Member

Oct 21, 2013

67

Nottingham, MD

sundazes said:

I would get a BFR in 45/70.

Click to expand...

If I put that in a holster the tip of the barrel would drag along the ground.

 

• Apr 19, 2019

• #13

Sundazes

Throbbing Member

MDS Supporter

Nov 13, 2006

21,537

Arkham

Luigi2020 said:

If I put that in a holster the tip of the barrel would drag along the ground.

Click to expand...

Shoulder holster should suffice.

 

• Apr 19, 2019

• #14

danb

dont be a dumbass

Feb 24, 2013

22,704

google is your friend, I am not.

Is that a BFR in your pocket or are you just happy to see me?

 

• Apr 19, 2019

• #15

SRD

R.I.P.

Mar 5, 2011

10,645

Gambrills/Crownsville and parts in between

Love my J frame for most carry situations.

https://www.mdshooters.com/showthread.php?p=4274336#post4274336

 

• Apr 19, 2019

• #16

TheOriginalMexicanBob

Ultimate Member

Jul 2, 2017

32,819

Sun City West, AZ

Look at the new model Colt Cobra...six round capacity vs. five in most competition offerings plus an excellent trigger. If you want a .357 the King Cobra will do in the nearly identical, but beefed up frame. If you prefer old school a Detective Special or lightweight Cobra does nicely. When I was a law officer and restricted to a revolver a Cobra was my regular companion.

 

• Apr 19, 2019

• #17

Stoveman

TV Personality

Patriot Picket

Sep 2, 2013

28,223

Cuba on the Chesapeake

S&W 442 Airweight

 

• Apr 19, 2019

• #18

fidelity

piled higher and deeper

MDS Supporter

Aug 15, 2012

22,400

Frederick County

I am fond of small revolver carry - and have a Kimber K6S (6 shot, 38 Special/357 Mag), Colt Cobra (2017 model, 6 shot, 38 Special), Ruger SP101 (5 shot, 38 Special/357 Mag), and S&W Model 60 (J-frame, 5 shot, 38 Special) as options. I can't get rid of any because I really like them all, and they shoot great at the range.

If on a trail, I like my SP101 with 3-inch barrel because 357 Magnum is very controllable with this gun, and it's still relatively small and easy to carry.

The K6S and Cobra are great all around options. I shoot the Cobra slightly better, but the K6S is so small and yet still manageable with no exposed hammer. Both the K6S and Cobra have excellent triggers - the K6S in DAO (super smooth and predictable) as well as the Cobra's SA (crisp) and DA (smooth and predictable) pull.

Some gratuitous pictures below (of the K6S, SP101, and Cobra, respectively)...

Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk

 

• Apr 19, 2019

• #19

Jed195

Ultimate Member

Oct 19, 2011

3,901

MD.

S&W Governor with 410 slugs. Hah

 

• Apr 19, 2019

• #20

Stoveman

TV Personality

Patriot Picket

Sep 2, 2013

28,223

Cuba on the Chesapeake

fidelity said:

I am fond of small revolver carry - and have a Kimber K6S (6 shot, 38 Special/357 Mag), Colt Cobra (2017 model, 6 shot, 38 Special), Ruger SP101 (5 shot, 38 Special/357 Mag), and S&W Model 60 (J-frame, 5 shot, 38 Special) as options. I can't get rid of any because I really like them all, and they shoot great at the range.

If on a trail, I like my SP101 with 3-inch barrel because 357 Magnum is very controllable with this gun, and it's still relatively small and easy to carry.

The K6S and Cobra are great all around options. I shoot the Cobra slightly better, but the K6S is so small and yet still manageable with no exposed hammer. Both the K6S and Cobra have excellent triggers - the K6S in DAO (super smooth and predictable) as well as the Cobra's SA (crisp) and DA (smooth and predictable) pull.

Some gratuitous pictures below (of the K6S, SP101, and Cobra, respectively)...

Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk

Click to expand...

The grips on that snake gun are completely badass.