Thanks guys. Got an email from rugged after the shot show confirming. I may get a rugged piston to see if I makes a difference on blowback. Just gotta get the can out of jail first.
It doesn't matter. They are literally the exact same piston, minus the slots in the SiCo one for timing the Osprey.
Henry Graham, one of the founders of Rugged, who designed the Obsidian, is also a former employee of SiCo, and worked on their products while he was there. He has said that it's fine to interchange the pistons.