Neither is in the class of the Dan Wesson 1911 Bobtail Commander (Guardian). But then again the DW costs twice as much for a reason. Mine is in 9mm as I prefer that for both competition and carry.
Have had one for 2 1/2 years. Great all around pistol. I use Wilson Combat Elite 8 round magazines and in a few thousand rounds only recall one failure shooting remanufacturerd ammo. It shoots anything straight. Reliable. I had a nice older 5" Kimber that I sold and missed having a 1911 in the lineup, so I bought the Remington. It's a better pistol than the Kimber. No regrets.