I'm 99% sure I'm gonna go with the pescador pro 120 for myself and 100 for her. Unless she wants a sit in, then probably a perception sound 10.5.
Gonna check them out this weekend and see how I feel about them in person.
One thing nobody's mentioned (so maybe it only applies to me) is that finesse fishing and casting can be more difficult from a sit-in. Mrs. GnR and I have had a Perception/Aquaterra Keowee 2 since 1994. She still absolutely hates casting from it. I can identify with her, since I often need to hold my hands higher than I normally would when fishing. This can be hard on the shoulders and more fatiguing when I'm casting frequently over extended periods of time ... and then need to paddle home against the tide. I find flipping and pitching much more difficult when my seat-bottom is at or below the waterline too.
Caveat - I'm comparing a sit-in to experience from a canoe or johnboat, since I haven't actually fished from a sit-on kayak ... yet. I did take my new kayak out on its maiden voyage this past Saturday, but didn't bring fishing tackle.