jcutonilli
Ultimate Member
- Mar 28, 2013
- 2,474
Agreed. But his reliance on Snowden and Scherr have been superseded by Heller, Heller II and McDonald.
As I understand it S&S were decided before Heller confirmed that the RKBA was an individual right and that in those cases only the Superintendent's designee acted appropriately.
I am not sure Snowden and Scherr have really been superseded. Both are state court decisions about state laws. Snowden did not make a 2A argument. Scherr made several arguments only one of which was a 2A argument.
Heller and McDonald, while addressing an individuals right, the courts have interpreted it to only really addresses handguns in the home. Woollard demonstrates that the state court would likely reach the same decision even after Heller and McDonald.