Glock 19 Gen5-Worth Replacing Gen 4?

songlaw · Sep 28, 2017

Hello, all.
I have seen pictures and videos of the new Glock 19 Gen5s. I have purchased in the past year, 2 Glock 19 Gen4s, one MOS and one not.

Of course, some of us tend to jump on the newest models, like moths to a flame.

Anyone have an opinion on whether the new features on the Gen5 is justify replacing an otherwise perfectly fine Gen4?

TheRussianNightmare · Sep 28, 2017

I will wait, and shoot them both, back to back, to see if there is a discernible difference in feel or performance.

Generally speaking, I don't like to by a new-to the-market product immediately. I prefer to wait a while, to make sure all of the kinks have been worked out.

Some Gen4s had the "brass to the face" issue, that seems to have since been resolved.

alucard0822 · Sep 28, 2017

probably not. Having handled a G5, and owning a G4, the new pistol's cutout at the bottom of the frontsrap is more annoying and uncomfortable than finger grooves, the ambi-slide stop isn't useful, and there isn't much of a difference in the trigger or elsewhere. I do like the bevel on the front of the slide, and hate the old serrated triggers, but that's about it. You are also starting out with few aftermarket parts, I like the Vickers controls for my 4th gen, not available on 5G, same with connectors and swapping other trigger parts. So guess it comes down to how much you like new for the sake of new, or hate finger grooves.

ken792 · Sep 28, 2017

I'm not a fan either of that notch on the front of the mag well. It uses the same connector angle as the Gen 4 on the trigger housing, so the trigger pull is still crap.

I'm about to replace my Gen 4 with my Gen 3 as my daily carry gun.

Benjamin · Sep 28, 2017

Would not replace a Gen 4. One of Glock's strongest appeals is the massive aftermarket available, not only are these Gen 5's lacking in full compatibility with previous gen's, but there's also not much out there as of yet. You will get a lot more out of saving the money and putting it into your Gen 4's, or a different new gun. From what I've seen and felt the Gen 5 is just a way for Glock to stay current with all the new models coming out from other companies. CZ P10C, FN 509, or the new M&P compact would be a more worthwhile replacement.

Even if you didn't have any Glocks yet I'd suggest a Gen 3 or 4 and put the savings into upgrades.

F-Stop · Sep 28, 2017

I was disappointed. Like above the cut out hit me perfectly to be annoying. I tried inserting mags and you can definitely catch the ledge just right to stop the mag from going in.

jollymon · Oct 27, 2017

Even with the new barrel on the 5 you still can't shoot lead bullets only jacketed, may not be a big deal to most of you be all my guns I reload for . my 3 and 4 have a Lone Wolfe barrel
So I can shoot cheaper bullets in but that was almost 200.00 upgrade

Fnh57 · Nov 1, 2017

Don't forget the improvements to the barrel. They say it is more accurate. This may be the best improvement if it's true.

redeemed.man · Nov 1, 2017

Fnh57 said:
Don't forget the improvements to the barrel. They say it is more accurate. This may be the best improvement if it's true.

Who has complained about the accuracy of a Glock in a prior generation? It's at least as accurate as any other service pistol out there going back to Gen 1. I can't imagine accuracy would be a strong reason to buy one for most folks. Trigger improvements, lack of finger grooves, and just the general "coolness" of having the latest gun would play more into differences with prior generations.

babalou · Nov 1, 2017

yup

TheRussianNightmare said:
I will wait, and shoot them both, back to back, to see if there is a discernible difference in feel or performance.

Generally speaking, I don't like to by a new-to the-market product immediately. I prefer to wait a while, to make sure all of the kinks have been worked out.

Some Gen4s had the "brass to the face" issue, that seems to have since been resolved.

until Service Pack 1, at least

woodline · Nov 1, 2017

I have carried and shot shot gen 3 and gen 4 Glocks for about 8-9 years. I handled a gen5 g19 this weekend. Not sure if it's on the MD registry yet. It seemed fine, minus the tongue cut into the front of the magwell. I am pretty sure I would pinch my pinky finger a few times before retraining myself.

I am keeping my gen4 g19, but I am buying a CZ P10C to try out.

Biggfoot44 · Nov 1, 2017

Rule of thumb - Don't buy somthing new until it has been 12 months successfully out there. That could be 12 months since introduction, or 12 months since recall or product improvement.

Blaster229 · Nov 1, 2017

Biggfoot44 said:
Rule of thumb - Don't buy somthing new until it has been 12 months successfully out there. That could be 12 months since introduction, or 12 months since recall or product improvement.

I bought a VP9 right out of the starting gate and it has been flawless. So, not really always the rule of thumb.

ironpony · Nov 1, 2017

Replacement, maybe not. Addition to one's collection, why not. Some enjoy the pistol hobby (buy it) and some will have one pistol just to have one (stick with what you know/).
I've got one on order and when I handled it I did not notice the mag removal groove but did notice a larger gap between the slide and the frame. I've also worn significant amounts of finish from the slides of the previous gen's and hope the new finish is more durable, leather and kydex (various holsters) seem to be tougher than the old Glock finish. I just checked google for your question and your MDS thread is #10 ! Good Luck.

ironpony · Nov 1, 2017

Blaster229 said:
I bought a VP9 right out of the starting gate and it has been flawless. So, not really always the rule of thumb.

+1

Stoveman · Nov 1, 2017

boundlessdyad said:
Who has complained about the accuracy of a Glock in a prior generation? It's at least as accurate as any other service pistol out there going back to Gen 1. I can't imagine accuracy would be a strong reason to buy one for most folks. Trigger improvements, lack of finger grooves, and just the general "coolness" of having the latest gun would play more into differences with prior generations.

He's trolling for posts and has been chop blocked recently.

redeemed.man · Nov 1, 2017

ironpony said:
Replacement, maybe not. Addition to one's collection, why not. Some enjoy the pistol hobby (buy it) and some will have one pistol just to have one (stick with what you know/).
I've got one on order and when I handled it I did not notice the mag removal groove but did notice a larger gap between the slide and the frame. I've also worn significant amounts of finish from the slides of the previous gen's and hope the new finish is more durable, leather and kydex (various holsters) seem to be tougher than the old Glock finish. I just checked google for your question and your MDS thread is #10 ! Good Luck.

If you want a tough finish you'll need to adopt a Gen 2. I carry one every day and it looks nearly new. Purchased in the early to mid 90's.

redeemed.man · Nov 1, 2017

Stoveman said:
He's trolling for posts and has been chop blocked recently.

One of those huh? Whatever happened to the guy who was copying and pasting posts from some other forum to pretend like he knew about guns?

alucard0822 · Nov 1, 2017

Biggfoot44 said:
Rule of thumb - Don't buy somthing new until it has been 12 months successfully out there. That could be 12 months since introduction, or 12 months since recall or product improvement.

Have had new pistols run great, and pistols that have been out for years have problems, some had problems well known for years, but the manufacturer never addressed. Plenty of recalls issued well more than a year too. Figure the "rule of thumb" is to buy firearms from companies that have good customer service, and that are willing to fix problems with minimal hassle if they arise, GLOCK is on that list. So if you like the gen 5s, buy one, if there is a problem, GLOCK will make it right if or when it pops up

molonlabe · Nov 1, 2017

Seems like a good place to ask this.
I have a gen1 with the unsupported chamber. In its life I had one case rupture that blew out rhe magazine otherwise there was no damage. I recently bought a Glock 43 for carry and it looks Like it's fully supported. Did Glock fix that problem in later generations.

Glock 19 Gen5-Worth Replacing Gen 4?

The #1 community for Gun Owners of the Northeast

Member Benefits:

Active Member

Active Member

For great Justice

Ultimate Member

Member

Ultimate Member

Active Member

Member

Ultimate Member

Ultimate Member

Ultimate Member

Ultimate Member

God loves you, I don't.

Member

Member

TV Personality

Ultimate Member

Ultimate Member

For great Justice

Ultimate Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Log in

Forum statistics