The challenge with giving someone that can't rack a slide a pre-loaded semi with a big magazine is what does she do if she limp wrists the Glock (yes, it is possible to limp wrist a Glock, I've seen it) and gets a stovepipe? She is in big trouble.
I'm a 1911 guy, so I appreciate your respect of it, but remember that the 1911 with a stock mag only holds 7 rounds, one more than most 4" revolvers. Even today's 8 round 1911 magazines are matched by many 8 shot revolvers. Here is a great article on the viability of the 8 shot revolver as a home defense firearm: https://www.shootingillustrated.com/articles/2015/11/23/eight-shot-alternatives-to-semi-autos/
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Smack the mag against a hard surface, rip the rear sight against a 90 degree angle (preferably the bad guys eye socket) and get back to business.
Reload a 1911 then reload a revolver and tell me which one you'd rather do in the dark sweating and panicked.